Southside
French Bakery & Cafe
The French Pantry
A legendary Jacksonville institution famous throughout Northeast Florida for scratch-baked arti...
View Profile →
✓ Verified Local
📍 Beaches
$$
Cinotti's Bakery & Sandwich Shop
A five-generation Jacksonville Beach legacy serving scratch-made donuts, Italian pastries, bespoke wedding cakes, colorful birthday creations, and fresh deli sandwiches since 1936.
Information last checked and verified: October 2026
About Cinotti's Bakery & Sandwich Shop
Located at 1523 Penman Road in Jacksonville's Beaches corridor, Cinotti's Bakery & Sandwich Shop operates as an authentic destination for scratch-made baked goods. Known throughout Northeast Florida for uncompromising culinary technique, this establishment specializes in Famous Pumpkin Spice Cake Donuts, Custom Birthday & Graduation Cakes, Handmade Italian Cannoli, Multi-Tier Wedding Cakes, Authentic Deli Sandwiches.
Whether stopping by for an early morning coffee and warm croissant, planning custom birthday cakes for milestone parties, or picking up hearth bread for the dinner table, guests experience genuine local craftsmanship. The bakery maintains consistent acclaim with a 4.7 out of 5 average rating across more than 1,820 customer reviews on Google.
Signature Menu Specialties
- ★ Famous Pumpkin Spice Cake Donuts
- ★ Custom Birthday & Graduation Cakes
- ★ Handmade Italian Cannoli
- ★ Multi-Tier Wedding Cakes
- ★ Authentic Deli Sandwiches
Menu & Price Estimates
Estimates based on in-store menus| Famous Pumpkin Spice Cake Donut Legendary autumn spiced cake donut with delicate translucent sugar glaze. | $2.25 |
| Classic Scratch Birthday Layer Cake (8") Traditional yellow or devil's food sponge with buttercream piping and message. | $38.00 – $55.00 |
| Sicilian Ricotta Cannoli Crisp hand-rolled pastry shell filled with sweet chocolate-chip ricotta. | $4.25 |
| Custom Multi-Tier Wedding Cake Generational beach wedding cake design with consultation and tasting. | $6.50 – $8.50 / slice |
*Note: Prices are estimates reflecting verified in-store menus and are subject to change based on seasonal ingredient costs and custom decoration specifications.
Ordering & Service Information
Walk-in Retail Counter
Online Pre-Ordering
Wedding Cake Consultations
Deli Breakfast & Lunch
Walk-in Visits: Guests are welcome to visit during regular operating hours to choose from the fresh daily display cases. For high-demand morning favorites, early arrival is advised before daily sell-outs occur.
Special & Custom Orders: For celebration cakes, custom event decorations, or large morning catering boxes, please call the counter directly at (904) 246-1728 or visit their official website to submit inquiries with sufficient lead time.
Verified Customer Reviews
★ 4.7 on Google (1,820+ reviews)
Brenda G.
Google Local Guide
★★★★★
"Five generations of excellence! We've bought our family birthday and graduation cakes here for 30 years and the pumpkin donuts are iconic."
Date: September 2026 • Verified Source
Jason F.
Yelp Elite Reviewer
★★★★★
"The Italian cannoli and custom tier cakes are unmatched. Cinotti's is a true Jacksonville Beach treasure with amazing deli subs."
Date: August 2026 • Verified Source
Melissa R.
Verified Customer
★★★★★
"The spiced pumpkin cake donuts in autumn are worth the line down Penman Road. Generous, friendly family service every time."
Date: July 2026 • Verified SourceLocation & Navigation
Related Jacksonville Bakery Guides
Bakery Guides
The Complete Jacksonville Bakery Guide: Top Spots for Bread, Cakes & Pastries
From legendary Powers Avenue baguettes to Murray Hill sourdough and Neptune Beach wedding cakes, here is your ...
Birthday Cakes
How to Choose a Birthday Cake in Jacksonville: Flavors, Sizing & Local Bakeries
Everything you need to select the perfect celebration cake in Jacksonville, including lead times, buttercream ...
Cakes
How Far Ahead Should You Order a Custom Cake in Jacksonville?
Don't get caught without a cake. A realistic booking calendar detailing lead times for birthday cakes, intrica...
Explore More
More Bakeries in Jacksonville
Southside
Springfield
Artisan Bakery & Cafe
1748 Bakehouse
Historic Springfield staple handcrafting scratch pies, flaky savory galettes, naturally leavene...
View Profile →
Riverside
Allergen-Friendly & Vegan Bakery
Sweet Theory Baking Co.
Riverside's acclaimed 100% egg, dairy, and peanut-free haven crafting celebrated scratch donuts...
View Profile →